American Rare Coins and Collectibles Review

Disclaimer: Teranga Gold independently determines what we cover and recommend. We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to availability and retailer terms.

In the fascinating world of rare coins and collectibles, American Rare Coins and Collectibles has emerged as a noteworthy player.

But does it live up to the hype?

As enthusiasts and collectors, we've taken a deep dive into what this company offers, its history, services, and how it stands in the competitive market. 

Investing your savings is a serious decision, especially when it involves precious metals. It's crucial to know which companies are reliable.

To help you, we've examined every precious metals company and identified a select few that you can trust.

Our Top Companies List allows you to quickly and easily evaluate the best gold companies, helping you find a company that aligns with your investment objectives and needs.

Or receive a complimentary Gold Information Kit from our top pick by clicking the button below:

Protect Your Retirement Savings - Without Taxes or Penalties!

Company Overview

American Rare Coins and Collectibles, with over 35 years of experience and a steadfast presence in Bloomington, MN, stands as a beacon for coin enthusiasts and investors.

This company isn't just a business; it's a gathering place for those who cherish the stories and value behind each collectible.

Their mission transcends the mere selling of items; it's about fostering a community where knowledge and passion for numismatics are shared freely. They specialize in a wide range of gold and silver products, rare coins, and currency, catering to a diverse clientele. 

What sets them apart is their upfront pricing, honest reputation, and commitment to prompt delivery, making them a reliable and trustworthy partner in the world of numismatics. Their team, boasting over 200 years of combined experience, is a testament to their depth of knowledge and dedication to the field.

This expertise is not just about understanding the market; it's about connecting with each client, understanding their needs, and guiding them through their numismatic journey.

History and Background 

American Rare Coins and Collectibles' journey from a small, enthusiast-driven venture to one of the Midwest's largest coin and bullion dealers is a story of passion, dedication, and expertise. Over the years, they have served over 100,000 satisfied customers, a number that speaks volumes about their reputation and trustworthiness.

Their longevity in the market, especially at their longstanding location, reflects their stability and commitment to the numismatic community. As active buyers of all forms of coins and precious metal bullion, they have continuously adapted to the evolving market, ensuring they meet the needs of both seasoned collectors and newcomers.

Their open and honest approach to pricing and market information sharing is a refreshing trait in an industry where transparency is key. This approach has not only earned them a great reputation but also a loyal customer base that values their integrity and expertise.

Services Offered

Appraisal Services

As indicated by our tests, American Rare Coins and Collectibles' appraisal services are a cornerstone of their offerings. Their team of experts meticulously evaluates each item, considering not just its market value but also its historical significance.

This thoroughness ensures that collectors receive a comprehensive understanding of their items' worth, which is crucial for insurance purposes, estate planning, or sales. Their appraisals are not just about assigning a dollar value; they're about providing a deeper insight into each item's place in history and its potential future value.

Consultation Services

The consultation services at American Rare Coins and Collectibles are tailored to meet the unique needs of each client. Whether you're just starting your collection or looking to expand it, their experts offer personalized advice and insights.

They help clients navigate the often complex world of numismatics, offering guidance on everything from portfolio diversification to the acquisition of rare pieces. Their approach is educational, ensuring that clients not only make informed decisions but also deepen their understanding and appreciation of their collections.

Auction Services

The auction services provided by American Rare Coins and Collectibles are a testament to their commitment to providing a comprehensive collector's experience. They expertly bridge the gap between buyers and sellers, facilitating transactions that are fair and beneficial for both parties.

Their auctions are not just about the exchange of goods; they're events where collectors can come together, share their passion, and find rare and valuable items that are often hard to come by. The company ensures a smooth and transparent auction process, making it an enjoyable and rewarding experience for all involved.

Products Offered

American Rare Coins and Collectibles impresses with a range of products that cater to various interests and investment levels. Their collection is a treasure trove for enthusiasts and investors alike.

Rare Coins

The rare coin selection at American Rare Coins and Collectibles is a journey through history. It includes ancient coins that date back to early civilizations, offering a glimpse into the past. These coins are not just metal pieces; they are artifacts that tell stories of empires, economies, and cultures.

The modern limited editions, on the other hand, represent the latest in numismatic craftsmanship, often commemorating significant events or figures. The company ensures that each coin's story is well-articulated, providing collectors with not just a piece of history, but a story that adds value to their collection.

Historical Memorabilia

The historical memorabilia collection at American Rare Coins and Collectibles is a curated selection of items that have witnessed the unfolding of history. This collection includes items from significant historical events and figures, like signed documents, medals, and artifacts from notable periods.

Each piece is carefully selected to ensure authenticity and historical value. For history buffs and collectors, these items offer a tangible connection to the past, making them not just collectibles but pieces of history that have stood the test of time.

Precious Metals

For those interested in precious metals, American Rare Coins and Collectibles offers a variety of options. Gold, silver, platinum, and palladium are available in different forms, such as coins, bars, and rounds.

This diversification allows investors to choose products that align with their investment strategies, whether they're looking for long-term stability with gold or the industrial demand-driven potential of palladium. The company provides detailed information on each metal, helping investors make informed decisions.

Storage and Security Measures

Drawing from our experience, at American Rare Coins and Collectibles, the security and preservation of your rare items are taken very seriously. They employ advanced security measures to ensure that every item, whether it's a rare coin, a piece of historical memorabilia, or precious metal, is stored under optimal conditions.

This includes controlled environments that prevent damage from humidity, temperature fluctuations, and other environmental factors. Moreover, their security protocols are robust, incorporating the latest in surveillance and alarm systems, ensuring that your investments are protected around the clock.

They understand that these items are not just financial investments but also carry sentimental and historical value, and their storage solutions reflect this understanding. Additionally, they offer advice and assistance in setting up secure storage solutions at your home or in a bank vault, depending on your preference and the nature of your collection.

Transparent Fee Structure

Transparency is a key aspect of the service provided by American Rare Coins and Collectibles. They pride themselves on having a clear and straightforward fee structure, which means you won't encounter any unexpected charges.

All fees are communicated upfront, whether you're buying, selling, or utilizing their appraisal services. This transparency extends to their buying and selling process as well. Prices for coins and collectibles are set based on current market values, ensuring fairness and honesty in every transaction.

This approach not only builds trust but also empowers you as a customer to make informed decisions. They also provide detailed receipts and documentation for all transactions, which is particularly helpful for those who are investing in coins and collectibles as part of a broader investment strategy or for estate planning purposes.

Customer Service and Support Excellence

The customer service team at American Rare Coins and Collectibles is a standout feature of the company. They are not just knowledgeable about coins and collectibles; they are also passionate about them.

This passion translates into a customer service experience that is both informative and engaging. Whether you are a seasoned collector or new to the world of numismatics, their team is ready to assist with any queries or concerns. 

They offer personalized service, taking the time to understand your interests and goals, and provide tailored advice accordingly. Their responsiveness is particularly commendable, with quick replies to emails, phone calls, and in-person inquiries.

This high level of customer service enhances the overall experience, making the process of buying, selling, or appraising coins and collectibles both enjoyable and educational. Additionally, they regularly gather feedback from clients to continuously improve their services and ensure that they meet the evolving needs of collectors and investors.

American Rare Coins and Collectibles Review - Yelp

Educational Resources  

American Rare Coins and Collectibles doesn't just stop at selling products; they take an active role in educating their clients. The website hosts a variety of educational resources that are easily accessible. These include informative articles and videos that cover a wide range of topics, from the basics of coin collecting to more advanced investment strategies.

This educational approach is invaluable, especially for newcomers to the world of coin collecting and investing. The company also shows a strong commitment to community engagement. They organize workshops and interactive sessions, which are great platforms for enthusiasts to connect, learn, and share experiences.

This focus on education and community is not just about building a customer base; it's about nurturing a passionate and informed community of collectors and investors. Their efforts in this area set them apart from many competitors, highlighting their role as not just a seller but a knowledgeable guide in the world of numismatics.

Comparative Analysis with Industry Standards

Comparing American Rare Coins and Collectibles to industry standards, it's clear that they hold a strong position, especially in their product range and commitment to customer education. Their product offerings are diverse, catering to a wide range of interests and investment levels.

This variety is crucial in the collectibles market, as it attracts both seasoned collectors and those new to the field. In terms of customer education, they excel, providing resources that empower clients to make informed decisions. 

However, there is room for improvement in their digital presence. While their website is user-friendly and informative, enhancing online interaction capabilities, such as live chat support or more interactive online tools, could further elevate the customer experience.

Additionally, expanding their digital marketing efforts could help them reach a broader audience, ensuring that more potential collectors and investors are aware of their services and expertise. Overall, their strong foundation in product variety and customer education sets them up well, but embracing more digital engagement tools could propel them to even greater heights in the industry.

Protect Your Retirement Savings - Without Taxes or Penalties!


In conclusion, American Rare Coins and Collectibles offers a comprehensive, reliable, and enjoyable experience for anyone interested in rare coins and collectibles.

While our review is based on thorough research and personal experience, we encourage potential clients to conduct their research to ensure the services and products meet their specific needs.

This company, with its rich history, diverse offerings, and commitment to customer service, stands as a notable entity in the world of rare collectibles.

Make sure to check out our compilation of The Top & Best Gold Companies to see if American Rare Coins and Collectibles   made the cut

If you find American Rare Coins and Collectibles appealing, explore more on their website by visiting the link below.

Scroll to Top