Is Great American Coin Company Legitimate

Is Great American Coin Company Legitimate?

Disclaimer: Teranga Gold independently determines what we cover and recommend. We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to availability and retailer terms.

In today's world, where the allure of precious metals and rare coins captivates many, the Great American Coin Company stands out as a significant player.

This article dives deep into the heart of their operations, exploring everything from their history and services to customer experiences. 

Join us as we unravel the facts and provide an unbiased look at what makes this company tick, ensuring you're well-informed about their legitimacy in the market.

Investing your savings is a serious decision, especially when it involves precious metals. It's crucial to know which companies are reliable.

To help you, we've examined every precious metals company and identified a select few that you can trust.

Our Top Companies List allows you to quickly and easily evaluate the best gold companies, helping you find a company that aligns with your investment objectives and needs.

Or receive a complimentary Gold Information Kit from our top pick by clicking the button below:

Protect Your Retirement Savings - Without Taxes or Penalties!

Company Overview

The Great American Coin Company, a family-owned business established in 2006, has carved a niche for itself in the precious metals and collectibles market. With a mission rooted in providing a diverse range of products, they have expanded their offerings to include not just rare coins but also a variety of precious metal bullion.

Their commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in their approach to business, prioritizing authenticity and in-depth knowledge in the field of numismatics and precious metals. This dedication is reflected in their diverse inventory, which caters to both seasoned collectors and new enthusiasts. 

Their core values, centered around integrity and customer-focused service, set them apart in a market that demands trust and expertise. As a member of the American Numismatic Association and an authorized reseller of NGC & PMG Products, they demonstrate a commitment to quality and authenticity in every aspect of their operation.

History and Background

Over the past decade, the Great American Coin Company has evolved from a small venture into a significant player in the industry. Founded by Gary Dyner, the company's journey began with a passion for gold, silver, and numismatic coin collecting.

This passion was further fueled in 2010 when Stephen Dyner joined the company, bringing expertise in business management and marketing. This combination of passion and professional acumen has enabled the company to adapt effectively to market changes and expand its product range. 

Their resilience and adaptability are key factors in their success, allowing them to navigate the competitive and often volatile market of precious metals and collectibles. The company's growth is not just a testament to its business acumen but also to its ability to understand and respond to the evolving needs of collectors and investors alike.

Services Offered

The Great American Coin Company offers a range of services that cater to a diverse clientele, including both collectors and investors.

Precious Metals Trading

Specializing in the trade of gold, silver, and platinum, the company offers a straightforward and transparent service. They provide a variety of options for those looking to invest in precious metals, whether it's for portfolio diversification, hedging against inflation, or simply for the love of collecting.

Their offerings are tailored to meet different investment thresholds and preferences, ensuring that both novice and experienced investors find value in their services.

Numismatic Expertise

The company's numismatic services are comprehensive, covering everything from appraisals to valuations. They cater to collectors of all levels, from those just starting out to seasoned enthusiasts with specific interests.

Their expertise in this area is not just about assessing the value of coins but also about understanding their historical significance, rarity, and collectibility. This service is particularly valuable for those looking to build or liquidate a collection, offering peace of mind that comes from dealing with knowledgeable professionals.

Investment Consultation

For those new to the world of precious metals or coin collecting, the company's investment consultation services are a boon. They provide tailored advice, helping clients navigate the complexities of investing in precious metals and collectibles.

This service is particularly beneficial in understanding market trends, assessing risk, and making informed decisions. Whether it's for long-term investment, retirement planning, or a hobby, their expert guidance ensures that clients make choices that align with their financial goals and interests.

Products Offered

The Great American Coin Company offers an extensive range of products, each with its unique appeal and value.


Their gold offerings are particularly impressive, catering to a wide audience of investors and collectors. The selection includes various forms of gold, such as American Eagle Bullion coins, which are highly sought after for their purity and design.

Additionally, they offer gold bars and rounds in different weights, providing options for both small-scale buyers and significant investors. The quality and authenticity of these gold products are a testament to the company's commitment to excellence. Each gold item is meticulously sourced and verified, ensuring that customers receive genuine and high-quality products.


The diversity in their silver collection is equally remarkable. From the iconic American Silver Eagles to pre-1965 US coins with 90% silver content, the variety caters to different tastes and budgets.

The company also offers silver bars and rounds, which are popular among those looking to invest in silver in a more substantial form. Collectors might find particular interest in their selection of silver certificates and international banknotes, which add a historical and cultural dimension to the collection.

Rare and Historic Coins and Notes

For enthusiasts of numismatics, the company's array of rare and historic coins and notes is a treasure trove. Each item in this category is steeped in history, offering more than just material value.

These pieces include Federal Reserve notes from 1929, showcasing a significant era in American financial history, and the Zimbabwe Banknotes, known for their hyperinflationary value. Collecting these items is not just about owning a piece of metal or paper; it's about holding a fragment of history in your hands.

Storage and Security

Based on our observations, the Great American Coin Company takes the security and storage of investments seriously. They understand that purchasing precious metals and rare coins is not just a financial decision but also an emotional one.

To ensure the safety and security of these valuable items, the company offers secure storage solutions. These solutions are designed to protect the physical integrity of the products and safeguard them against theft or loss. The storage facilities are equipped with state-of-the-art security systems, including surveillance and restricted access, ensuring that your investments are safe and sound.

Fees and Pricing

In terms of fees and pricing, the Great American Coin Company stands out for its transparency and competitiveness. They have a clear pricing model that allows customers to understand exactly what they are paying for. The prices of their products are regularly updated to reflect the current market value of precious metals, ensuring that customers get a fair deal.

Moreover, the company does not charge hidden fees, which is a significant advantage for buyers who want to make informed and straightforward purchases. Their competitive pricing, combined with the quality of their products and services, makes them a reliable choice for anyone looking to invest in precious metals or rare coins.

Customer Service and Support

When we interacted with the Great American Coin Company's customer service team, we were impressed by their deep knowledge and quick responsiveness.

They didn't just answer our questions; they provided insights that only experts in the field could offer. This level of expertise is crucial, especially in a niche market like numismatics and precious metals. 

Customers often have specific, detailed queries, and the staff's ability to address these efficiently is a testament to their training and experience. Furthermore, their approach to customer service goes beyond mere transactional interactions.

They focus on building relationships, offering personalized advice and guidance. This approach fosters a sense of trust and loyalty among customers, which is invaluable in any business but particularly so in one dealing with valuable collectibles and investments.

Online Presence and User Experience

Exploring the Great American Coin Company's website, we found it to be more than just a digital storefront. It's an informative hub, rich with resources that cater to both seasoned collectors and newcomers to the world of numismatics and precious metals. The website's design is intuitive, making it easy for visitors to find what they're looking for, whether it's specific products, educational content, or market insights. 

The product descriptions are detailed, providing essential information that buyers need to make informed decisions. Additionally, the website is regularly updated with the latest offerings and market news, which keeps it relevant and engaging. This active online presence demonstrates the company's commitment to staying connected with its audience and adapting to the evolving digital landscape.

Industry Reputation

Our research into the Great American Coin Company's standing in the industry revealed a generally positive reputation. They are recognized for their extensive product range and expertise in precious metals and rare coins.

This recognition comes not just from customers but also from peers within the industry. Being a member of the American Numismatic Association and an authorized reseller of NGC & PMG products further bolsters their credibility. 

However, like any company, they face their share of critiques. Some industry observers point out areas where they could improve, such as offering more competitive pricing or expanding their range of rare international coins.

These critiques, while noteworthy, do not significantly detract from the company's overall reputation. Instead, they offer opportunities for growth and improvement, which is crucial for any business looking to maintain its standing in a competitive market.


What makes the Great American Coin Company stand out in the coin and precious metal market?

The Great American Coin Company distinguishes itself through its extensive product range, including rare and historic coins, and its commitment to customer education and satisfaction. Their transparent pricing and comprehensive numismatic services cater to both seasoned collectors and new investors, setting them apart in the market.

How does the Great American Coin Company ensure the authenticity of its coins and precious metals?

The company employs rigorous authentication and appraisal processes, conducted by experienced numismatists. They utilize advanced techniques and tools to verify the authenticity of each item, ensuring that customers receive genuine and high-quality products.

Can beginners in coin collecting or precious metal investments easily navigate the services of the Great American Coin Company?

Yes, beginners can find the Great American Coin Company's services user-friendly. Their website offers educational resources, and their customer service team is equipped to guide newcomers through the nuances of coin collecting and precious metal investments, making the process accessible and informative.

Are there any educational resources available for clients of the Great American Coin Company?

The company provides a wealth of educational resources on their website. These resources cover various topics related to coin collecting and precious metal investments, offering valuable insights for both novices and experienced collectors or investors.

Protect Your Retirement Savings - Without Taxes or Penalties!

Final Thoughts

After trying out this service, we can conclude that the Great American Coin Company is a business that is committed to its customers and operates with integrity. 

Whether you are a seasoned collector, a precious metal investor, or new to this field, this company offers a reliable platform for your needs. As always, we recommend doing your own research and due diligence before making any investment.

Make sure to check out our compilation of The Top & Best Gold Companies to see if Great American Coin made the cut

If you find Great American Coin appealing, explore more on their website by visiting the link below.

Scroll to Top