Rare Coins of New Hampshire Review

Disclaimer: Teranga Gold independently determines what we cover and recommend. We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to availability and retailer terms.

Since 1989, Rare Coins of New Hampshire has made a name for itself in the numismatic market, offering an impressive range of rare and historical coins.

Situated in Milford, New Hampshire, this firm is renowned for its expertise and commitment to quality.

Our article will guide you through their services, from detailed coin grading to customer-centric educational resources, giving you a comprehensive look at what makes RCNH a trusted name in coin collecting.

Investing your savings is a serious decision, especially when it involves precious metals. It's crucial to know which companies are reliable.

To help you, we've examined every precious metals company and identified a select few that you can trust.

Our Top Companies List allows you to quickly and easily evaluate the best gold companies, helping you find a company that aligns with your investment objectives and needs.

Or receive a complimentary Gold Information Kit from our top pick by clicking the button below:

Protect Your Retirement Savings - Without Taxes or Penalties!

What to expect from this article:

  • Background and services of Rare Coins of New Hampshire.
  • An overview of the types of coins available at RCNH.
  • Details on RCNH's coin grading process.
  • Information on customer service and educational resources provided by RCNH.
  • A comparison of RCNH with other numismatic services.
  • Customer testimonials and feedback about RCNH.

Company Overview

Established in 1989, Rare Coins of New Hampshire (RCNH) has developed a strong presence in the numismatic industry through dedicated service and professionalism. As a firm that is recognized as an authorized dealer for both PCGS and NGC, RCNH assures quality and adheres to the highest industry standards.

This establishment is also a member of the Industry Council for Tangible Assets (ICTA), which underscores its commitment to ethical practices and continuous education within the numismatic community. 

The leadership team at RCNH brings together a unique blend of personal experience and professional service, aiming to cater to the diverse needs of coin collectors and investors alike. Over the years, their approach has not only been about trading coins but fostering a community where knowledge and passion for numismatics flourish.

Types of Coins Offered

From what we’ve seen, RCNH offers a diverse range of coins that caters to a wide audience—from the casual hobbyist to the serious investor. Their inventory includes an array of U.S. coins across various eras, notable for their historical significance and potential investment value. Moreover, RCNH specializes in gold and silver coins, providing options for those interested in precious metals. 

Their collection also features modern and commemorative issues, appealing to collectors looking for specific themes or completing particular sets. Each coin category is carefully selected to ensure authenticity and quality, with offerings that are both wide-ranging and curated to meet the high standards of collectors and investors.

Examples of coins available include:

  • 1915 Lincoln Cent CACG PR-66 Red-Brown Matte Finish
  • 1942 Lincoln Cent PCGS PR-65 Red
  • 1938-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar CACG MS-65
  • 1881-CC Morgan Dollar CACG MS-63
  • 1905 Liberty $2.50 Gold Piece PCGS MS-64

The Grading Process  

The grading process at RCNH is meticulous, focusing on ensuring each coin's authenticity and condition are accurately assessed. This critical evaluation is conducted according to the standards established by top grading services such as PCGS and NGC, which helps maintain trust and reliability in every transaction. RCNH’s commitment to precise grading supports the coin's value retention and helps collectors make informed decisions. 

Grading also involves detailed inspections and sometimes consultations with top experts to ensure accuracy, providing collectors with additional confidence in their purchases. This attention to detail in the grading process is part of RCNH’s broader commitment to excellence in the numismatic field, ensuring each customer’s satisfaction and the long-term reputation of their collections.

Customer Service and Educational Resources

At Rare Coins of New Hampshire (RCNH), the commitment to exceptional customer service is evident through their comprehensive approach to engaging with both new and seasoned collectors.

From our experience, the company not only provides personal consultations but also offers an array of educational resources designed to enhance the numismatic knowledge of their clients. 

The staff at RCNH, including noted figures like Warren Mills and Joseph Presti, bring decades of experience to these interactions, ensuring that clients receive well-informed advice and insights into their potential investments. This level of service caters especially to those who value a deeper understanding of numismatics beyond mere transactional relationships.

Moreover, RCNH's online resources are robust. Their website includes detailed descriptions and histories of various coins, up-to-date market news, and practical collecting tips. This dedication to education helps demystify the complexities of coin collecting and investing, making it more accessible to a broader audience. The educational content available through RCNH not only informs but also enriches the collecting experience by connecting enthusiasts with the broader historical and economic contexts of the items they collect.  

Protect Your Retirement Savings - Without Taxes or Penalties!

Comparing RCNH with Other Numismatic Services

When juxtaposed with other numismatic services, RCNH distinguishes itself through its extensive inventory and the depth of expertise offered by its staff. However, there are areas where RCNH might not meet the needs of every potential customer.

For instance, RCNH does not provide services related to precious metal Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), which could be a crucial factor for investors looking to diversify retirement portfolios with precious metals. Additionally, RCNH's relatively limited presence on major consumer review platforms may lead potential customers to feel there is insufficient external feedback to fully assess the company's services.

This limited online presence could impact those who rely heavily on customer reviews to make informed decisions. By comparison, other numismatic firms might offer a broader range of services, including IRAs and have a more robust online review presence, providing a different kind of reassurance to potential clients.

Despite this, RCNH's long-standing reputation, supported by their affiliations with reputable organizations like PCGS and NGC, and their detailed educational resources, positions them well within the industry. They offer a wealth of knowledge and a personalized approach to service that many collectors and investors find invaluable. 

Testimonials and Customer Feedback

Rare Coins of New Hampshire (RCNH) has established a reputation for professionalism and a depth of knowledge in the numismatic field. However, it's essential to address the scarcity of online reviews and ratings. The limited feedback available online may give new customers pause as they seek validation from external sources.

From the reviews that are available, RCNH receives a relatively high rating, with a 4.5-star rating from 54 reviews on a local chamber of commerce site, reflecting positive customer experiences overall. Customers appreciate the prompt service and reasonable pricing, particularly noting the conservative grading of raw coins, which adds a layer of trustworthiness to their purchases.

Moreover, the insights from the staff on the value of items brought in for sale or appraisal seem to resonate well with clients, adding to the satisfaction reported in these interactions.

Despite these positive reports, the lack of extensive reviews on more widely recognized platforms like the Better Business Bureau (BBB), where RCNH is not accredited, raises questions about the broader perception and transparency of the business. This lack of external validation through mainstream review platforms could be a consideration for potential clients looking for reassurance from a broad user base.

Overall, while RCNH appears to uphold a strong commitment to customer service and expertise in the field, potential customers might need to rely more heavily on direct inquiries and personal engagement with the dealer to establish their own comfort and trust due to the limited number of online reviews.

Pros & Cons of Rare Coins of New Hampshire


  • Expertise and Professionalism: RCNH is known for its high level of expertise and professionalism in the numismatics industry, with a well-qualified team that offers personalized service.
  • Quality and Authenticity: As an authorized dealer of PCGS and NGC, RCNH provides coins that are accurately graded and authenticated, ensuring quality and reliability for collectors.
  • Educational Resources: RCNH offers extensive educational resources and personal consultations, aiming to enhance the knowledge and experience of both novice and seasoned collectors.
  • Wide Selection of Coins: The company boasts a diverse inventory that includes U.S. coins, gold and silver bullion, and other numismatic items, catering to a wide range of collectors' interests.
  • Longevity in the Market: Established in 1989, RCNH has demonstrated resilience and credibility in the numismatic market over decades.
  • Comprehensive Online Presence: Their website is rich with informative content, including news articles and FAQs, which supports both learning and ease of transaction from home.


  • Lack of Customer Reviews: There is a noticeable scarcity of customer reviews and ratings on widely recognized platforms, which may concern new customers looking for external opinions.
  • Not BBB Accredited: RCNH does not have accreditation from the Better Business Bureau (BBB), which might be a red flag for some potential customers regarding transparency and trustworthiness.
  • Limited Services for Investors: The absence of services related to precious metal IRAs might limit options for investors looking to include such items in their retirement planning.
  • Limited Review Site Presence: Their limited presence on review sites could make it challenging for potential customers to find broad feedback and evaluate the company's reputation.


How does RCNH support new coin collectors who are just starting their collections?

RCNH offers a variety of resources aimed specifically at new coin collectors. Their website features an array of educational articles and FAQs that provide insights into starting a coin collection, understanding the nuances of coin grading, and making informed purchasing decisions.

Additionally, RCNH staff are known for their willingness to provide personalized advice and consultations to help newcomers navigate their early experiences in numismatics.

Can RCNH assist with the liquidation of an estate that includes a collection of rare coins?

Yes, RCNH provides services tailored to the liquidation of estates that include coin collections. They offer appraisals and can facilitate the sale of rare coins, ensuring that the process is handled with sensitivity and expertise.

Their extensive experience in the numismatic market allows them to accurately assess the value of a collection and advise on the best methods for sale, whether through direct purchase or auction.

What options are available for someone looking to sell their coins to RCNH?

Individuals interested in selling their coins to RCNH have several options. They can directly contact RCNH to arrange a private consultation, where their coins will be appraised by expert numismatists.

For those who cannot visit in person, RCNH also provides guidance on securely shipping coins to their office for evaluation. This flexibility ensures that sellers from various locations can access RCNH's services conveniently and securely.

Protect Your Retirement Savings - Without Taxes or Penalties!


RCNH embodies a blend of tradition and expertise in the numismatic field, making it a reputable choice for coin collectors and investors. While it showcases a robust selection and significant industry knowledge, prospective customers should consider the limited external reviews when deciding on their numismatic partner.

Make sure to check out our compilation of The Top & Best Gold Companies to see if Rare Coins of New Hampshire made the cut

If you find Rare Coins of New Hampshire appealing, explore more on their website by visiting the link below.

Scroll to Top